Welcome to the cozy corner of Pawcatuck, Connecticut, where you can find a little slice of heaven at The Pizza Lady. Nestled at 50 Liberty St, this charming establishment perfectly melds the flavors of traditional Italian cuisine with a modern American twist, specializing in pizza that captivates the palate and warms the soul.

The ambiance here is casual yet inviting, making it an ideal spot whether you're stopping by for takeout or enjoying a leisurely meal with friends. The restaurant features outdoor seating and offers all the utilities you could want including delivery, reservations, and even catering services. Plus, it's a kid-friendly environment, complete with Wi-Fi for the tech-savvy diners.

At The Pizza Lady, the stars of the menu are undoubtedly the oven-fresh pizzas. Among the crowd favorites are the Soupy Pizza, a fan-favorite that has earned rave reviews, and the White Pizza, rich with garlic and ricotta. Customer Mark S. describes the Soupy Pizza as “great,” while Birdie M. emphasizes its irresistible nature, saying you might end up wanting the whole pie. This is food that doesn't just fill your stomach; it fills your heart.

• Signature Pizzas: Try the unique Fish Pizza, or indulge in Spicy Hot and Sweet options, all crafted with care.
• Hot Grinders: Options like the Bacon Cheeseburger and Chicken Parmesan grinders have become local legends and will surely satisfy your cravings as well.
• Customer Experience: The team at The Pizza Lady, exemplified by attentive staff like Susie, ensures that your order is just as you desire. Their dedication to customer service shines through, making every visit a positive experience.

Reviewers rave about the welcoming ambiance and the attention to special dietary needs—from vegan to meat-lover—making it clear that The Pizza Lady is committed to serving every guest. With 68 years of service under their belt, this eatery is a cherished staple in the Pawcatuck community. Whether you choose to dine in or take out, you'll leave satisfied, perhaps even a little misty-eyed, just like Dawn L. after her memorable experience.

With a menu filled with comforting Italian-American delights and a team dedicated to hospitality, The Pizza Lady is not just a place to eat; it’s a culinary journey that you will long remember. Make sure to stop by next time you’re in the area, and don’t forget to indulge in that delicious Soupy Pizza—you might find yourself returning for more!

For more information or to place an order, call (860) 599-1113. Experience the magic of The Pizza Lady, where every slice tells a story.